TegoSafe
EN

How to judge a vault app before you put your passport in it

Before you put a passport in a vault app, check its privacy label, its encryption, what happens if you forget the passcode, and where backups go.

You have a vault app open in the App Store, and the photo of your passport is in your camera roll. Give the app ten minutes before you move the passport in. Most answers are on its own pages, and a missing answer tells you something.

Are photo vault apps safe?

Not by default. The icon and the reviews do not tell you how an app stores your files. Apple's page on App Store privacy information says that information "is self-reported by the developer". The checks below are yours to do.

What to check before you trust one

  1. The App Store page and the privacy policy come first. In the App Privacy section, the answer you want for a vault is "Data Not Collected". On Apple's privacy labels page, that label reads "The developer does not collect any data from this app". Apple's guide for developers says data processed only on the phone is not "collected". A vault that keeps everything on the phone can say it honestly. Avoid a vault that lists Data Used to Track You. Apple's App Review Guidelines (5.1.1) say every app must link a privacy policy. Search it for "analytics", "advertising" and "server".

  2. Somebody makes the app, and you should be able to find them. A small developer with a website and a support address is fine. The same guidelines (5.1.1(v)) tell developers to let people use an app without creating an account if it has no real account features. A vault that keeps your files on the phone does not need an account. If the app asks for your email, find out why. It may be for a passcode reset, a copy on the maker's server, or marketing.

  3. A good encryption answer looks like "AES-256-GCM". AES is a NIST standard in three key lengths, AES-128, AES-192 and AES-256. GCM is a NIST mode that also detects changes to the file. If a page praises its encryption but names no algorithm, ask the developer which one.

  4. The keys should be made on your phone, and the maker should never get a copy. If the maker can reset your passcode by email, something other than your passcode can open the vault. Either the maker keeps a way in, or the passcode guards the screen and not the files. Decide whether you accept that.

    With a recovery code on paper, you can get back in, and so can anyone who finds the paper. With no reset and no code, a forgotten passcode means lost files.

Why pick A vault with no passcode reset

  • You accept that a forgotten passcode and a lost recovery code mean lost files.

Why skip A vault with no passcode reset

  • You may forget the passcode and have no recovery code on paper.

Checked on

  1. Look at the copies outside the vault. These are the backup and the original photo. A backup may go nowhere, to your own iCloud, or to the maker's server. Apple's iCloud Backup page says iCloud Backup includes app data for the apps on your device. A good answer says the files are encrypted on the phone before any copy leaves it. Importing a photo also puts a copy in the app. If the original stays in Photos, the passport is still in your camera roll, and in iCloud Photos if that is on. If you delete it, read how to remove a deleted ID photo.

  2. You should be able to export every file as a normal photo or PDF, at no cost. Without export, your files stay in that app, and you cannot move them to another one.

  3. An outside review is worth something when the app names the firm, the date and what was checked. "Audited" with no name is a claim you cannot check. With no independent audit, you are trusting the developer's word.

What about calculator vault apps?

A calculator vault looks like a calculator on your Home Screen and opens when you type a code. The disguise changes the icon. It says nothing about how the files are stored, so run the same list on it.

TegoSafe's answers to the same checks

TegoSafe's own pages answer each check:

  • Account: none. No sign-in, no email, no TegoSafe server and no analytics.
  • Encryption: AES-256-GCM from Apple's own libraries. The keys are made on your iPhone.
  • Forgotten passcode: no email reset. A printed recovery card reopens Documents. On a new phone it opens them from your TegoSafe backup, so turn backup on and keep the card.
  • Backup: optional. With backup on, only encrypted files go to your own iCloud.
  • The original: once your backup and recovery card are set, TegoSafe offers to remove it from Photos.
  • Export: always free.

The scan and your first 25 documents are free. See how it is protected and what it costs.

I forgot my vault app passcode. Can I get my photos back?

Only if the app has a reset or you saved its recovery code. Look in the app's help pages for a reset, then write to the developer. If the app was built with no reset, nobody can get you back in, including the developer.

Does moving a photo into a vault remove it from iCloud Photos?

Not unless the original is deleted from Photos. If the original stays in Photos and iCloud Photos is on, the photo is still in iCloud. Check what the app does with the original.

We make TegoSafe, an iPhone app for locking documents. This guide works without it.