What does end-to-end encryption mean for your iCloud photos?
End-to-end means only your devices hold the keys. Apple lists which iCloud data is end-to-end by default, which needs Advanced Data Protection, and the steps.
You check where your passport photo goes in iCloud, and the page says it is "encrypted". The word covers two arrangements. The difference is who holds the key.
What does end-to-end mean in iCloud?
Think of a locked box in the post. In one arrangement the post office keeps a copy of your key. In the other, only you and the person you send it to have a key. The second is what Apple calls end-to-end. The two ends are your devices, and nothing in between can open the box.
Apple's iCloud data security overview describes it the same way. End-to-end encrypted data can be decrypted only on your trusted devices where you are signed in to your Apple Account. Apple says no one else can access that data, not even Apple, and Apple cannot recover it for you.
What is the difference between encrypted on the server and end-to-end in iCloud?
Apple's default is called standard data protection. The same page says your iCloud data is encrypted in transit and stored in an encrypted format at rest. The keys from your trusted devices are secured in Apple data centers, so Apple can decrypt your data on your behalf. That is how it helps when you forget your password or restore a new phone.
Both are encryption. Standard protection covers the wire and the disk. Apple's end-to-end also keeps the key away from the company that holds the disk. To know what a company can read, find out who holds the key.
Which iCloud data is end-to-end by default?
Apple's table lists 15 data categories that are always protected by end-to-end encryption, with or without Advanced Data Protection:
- Passwords and Keychain
- Health data
- Journal data
- Home data
- Messages in iCloud
- Payment information
- Apple Card transactions
- Maps
- QuickType Keyboard learned vocabulary
- Safari
- Screen Time
- Siri information
- Wi-Fi passwords
- W1 and H1 Bluetooth keys
- Memoji
Messages in iCloud has a condition. By default it is end-to-end only when iCloud Backup is off, because a backup holds a copy of the Messages key.
Which iCloud data is end-to-end only with Advanced Data Protection?
Advanced Data Protection raises the count to 25. The ones that matter for documents are iCloud Backup, iCloud Drive, Photos and Notes. The table also lists Reminders, Safari Bookmarks, Shortcuts, Voice Memos, Wallet passes and Freeform.
Without it, all of these are encrypted in transit and on the server, and Apple holds the keys. A passport photo in iCloud Photos is in that group. So is a scan in iCloud Drive. Which of the two holds your photo is covered in iCloud Photos and iCloud Backup.
What does Advanced Data Protection still leave open?
Apple's page lists limits. iCloud Mail, Contacts and Calendars stay under standard protection. So do iWork collaboration, Shared Albums in Photos, and anything you share with "anyone with the link". Some metadata also stays under standard protection, such as modification dates, file sizes and checksums.
There is a cost too. With Advanced Data Protection on, Apple does not have the keys and cannot help you recover your data. Apple says you are guided to set up at least one recovery method first.
How do you turn on Advanced Data Protection?
Apple's page on turning on Advanced Data Protection lists what you need. That is an Apple Account with two-factor authentication and a passcode or password on your device. Every device signed in to your Apple Account needs updated software, and an iPhone needs iOS 16.2 or later. Managed Apple Accounts and child accounts are not eligible.
Turn on Advanced Data Protection on iPhone
- Open iCloud
Open the Settings app, tap your name, then tap iCloud.
- Find the setting
Scroll down, tap Advanced Data Protection, then tap Turn on Advanced Data Protection.
- Set a recovery method
Follow the onscreen instructions to review your recovery methods and enable Advanced Data Protection.
Apple says a recovery contact is a trusted friend or family member who can help you regain access. A recovery key is a secret 28-character code. Apple says your recovery methods are never shared with or known to Apple.
Turning it on for one device turns it on for your whole account. The same page says web access to your data at iCloud.com is then disabled. If you turn web access on again, a trusted device can approve temporary access. You can turn Advanced Data Protection off at any time. On an iPhone, open Settings, tap your name, tap iCloud, scroll down and turn off Advanced Data Protection.
Encrypted on your iPhone before it reaches iCloud
Without Advanced Data Protection, a passport photo in iCloud Photos is stored with keys Apple holds. TegoSafe makes its keys on your iPhone and has no server and no account. A locked document is encrypted on the phone. With backup on, only those encrypted files go to your own iCloud, with or without Advanced Data Protection, and Apple cannot read what is in them. Once your backup and recovery card are set, TegoSafe offers to remove the original from Photos.
The scan and your first 25 documents are free. See how it is protected. The article on how to judge a vault app lists the questions to ask any app that says "encrypted".
Is iCloud end-to-end encrypted?
Only in part. Apple lists 15 data categories as always end-to-end, such as Passwords and Keychain and Health data. Photos and iCloud Backup are end-to-end only with Advanced Data Protection.
Can Apple read my iCloud Photos?
With standard data protection, Apple holds the keys and can decrypt the photos on your behalf. With Advanced Data Protection, your trusted devices hold the keys, and Apple's page says no one else can access the data, not even Apple.
We make TegoSafe, an iPhone app for locking documents. This guide works without it.